Skip to content

Why Is Your Electric Bill So High in Winter?

4 min

Quick answer: In most all-electric Central Texas homes, a high winter bill comes from heat strips running on cold nights, a heat pump working harder as the temperature drops, and heat lost through attic ducts and thin insulation. Space heaters, an electric water heater and long evenings with the lights on add to it.

In this guide
  1. Why is my winter electric bill higher than summer?
  2. Are heat strips making my electric bill so high?
  3. Can leaky ducts and a cold attic raise a winter bill?
  4. What else runs up a winter bill?
  5. How can I lower my winter electric bill?
  6. Is a high winter bill a sign my heat pump is broken?
  7. What should you do next?

Why is my winter electric bill higher than summer?

Because on a cold night your heating system fights a bigger temperature gap than your AC does on most summer days. In July the AC holds 75°F against 100°F outside, a 25-degree difference. On a 30°F January night the heat holds 70 against 30, a 40-degree difference, and it keeps at it all night.

Add heat strips, which use far more power per unit of heat than a heat pump, and a few cold weeks can outdo a mild summer month. Gas-heated homes see less of this on the electric bill, since the furnace burns gas and only the blower runs on electricity. In an all-electric house, winter is when the heating system shows its true colors.

Are heat strips making my electric bill so high?

In many homes, yes. A heat pump in mild weather delivers roughly two to three units of heat for each unit of electricity it uses. The electric heat strips that back it up deliver one.

Strips come on when it’s too cold for the heat pump to keep up, during defrost, after big overnight thermostat turn-downs, and whenever someone leaves the system on Emergency Heat. A 10 kW strip uses 10 kilowatt-hours an hour, so a cold week with the strips running half the night shows up fast. Aux heat vs. emergency heat explains what your thermostat is doing.

Can leaky ducts and a cold attic raise a winter bill?

Yes, often by a lot. In most Central Texas homes the air handler and ducts sit in the attic, which on a winter night is nearly as cold as outdoors. The supply side is typically a ductboard plenum (the main box on the air handler) with flex runs to each room, and every leaky joint, torn outer jacket or loose connection dumps warm air into that cold attic before it reaches you.

Leaky return ducts make it worse by pulling cold attic air back in, and thin attic insulation lets more heat escape through the ceiling. How leaky ducts pull attic air into your home and what R-value attic insulation you need in Austin cover both.

What else runs up a winter bill?

Plenty that has nothing to do with the thermostat:

  • Space heaters are a factor. Most plug-in models draw up to 1,500 watts on high, and they’re pure resistance heat, just like a heat strip. Two running all evening add up. See using space heaters alongside central heat.
  • An electric water heater uses more in winter. The water coming into the house is colder in winter, so every shower takes more energy to heat.
  • Long nights add up. Lights, TVs and computers run more hours when it’s dark at 5:30.
  • Holiday guests and cooking add more load. More showers, more laundry, more oven time.
  • A fan set to ON runs the blower nonstop, which uses power and moves air past cold attic ducts. See fan ON or AUTO.

How can I lower my winter electric bill?

Start with the free fixes, then work on the house. None of it needs new equipment.

  • Set the heat around 68°F while you’re home, and with a heat pump, turn it down only a few degrees at night so the strips don’t run at dawn.
  • Make sure Emergency Heat is off.
  • Change the filter, since poor airflow makes everything run longer.
  • Close curtains at night, and open south-facing ones on sunny days.
  • Have the ducts checked for leaks and disconnected runs, and seal what turns up.
  • Bring attic insulation up to a sensible level for Central Texas.

Is a high winter bill a sign my heat pump is broken?

It can be, when the jump doesn’t match the weather. Compare kilowatt-hours, not dollars, with the same month last year and with how cold it actually got. A big jump in a mild month can mean the heat pump isn’t heating at all and the strips are carrying the house.

Watch for three signs: the outdoor unit sits idle while the heat is on, the thermostat shows Aux most of the day, or the outdoor unit wears a coat of ice that never clears. A stuck reversing valve (the part that switches the system between heating and cooling), a refrigerant leak or a thermostat wired or set up wrong can each cause it. Why a heat pump runs nonstop below freezing covers what’s normal on the coldest nights.

Gold Eagle’s technicians diagnose heat pumps and check attic ducts in homes across the Austin area; see our heat pump services.

What should you do next?

  • Check that the thermostat isn’t set to Emergency Heat, and watch how often it shows Aux on a cold day.
  • Look at the outdoor unit while the heat is on: it should be running, and any frost should clear during defrost.
  • Compare this bill’s kilowatt-hours with the same month last year before assuming something is broken.
  • If the numbers don’t add up, book a visit to check the heat pump and the attic ducts.

Related guides: Aux Heat vs. Emergency Heat: What Your Heat Pump Thermostat Is Telling You, Why Does My Heat Pump Run Nonstop When It’s Below Freezing? and Leaky Ducts: How They Pull Attic Air and Dust Into Your Home.


About Gold Eagle Services: This guide comes from the team at Gold Eagle Services, a family-run Austin HVAC, indoor air quality and mold remediation company founded in 2017. We’re licensed (TACLA119235 and RCO1783), insured and bonded, and we serve homes across the greater Austin area.

Need help with this in your home? Learn about our heat pump repair and service, or call 512-489-4653 to schedule a visit.

Related Gold Eagle service: Heating service

Same-day service
BookTextCall 512-489-4653Call